Will my iPad put the smackdown on my netbook?

Last weekend, a farmer friend tweeted and buzzed the following comment “Just saw my first iPad in the wild…looks like someone ripped the keyboard (and full OS) off of a netbook. And then doubled the price.”   I had to comment on the buzz and from there, a string of convo took place with the biggest focus being on Apple vs. PC value, marketing, etc .  You can see it here but I wanted to take a few minutes and write my review of the iPad as well as it’s fit versus my netbook (I claimed to have domesticated both in my buzz reply).

One note before I go further, I will confess what close friends & family have known for sometime — I am a technology geek. I absolutely LOVE having good cameras, computers, etc. and enjoy sharing my story and images with others. To do that, I invest in it personally.  For work, I continue to use the standard issue corporate computer — don’t anticipate our office IT team supplying toys with this sort of bells & whistles anytime soon.  Now, back to the review.  🙂

First, on the specs for my iPad:

  • I have the 64 gig with 3G
  • Pre-ordered so I got it the day the 3G came out
  • Accessories bought: the case & the card readers for my cameras
  • Apps I’ve installed: Pages (word processing), NY Times, The Weather Channel, WordPress, backgammon, twitterific, IM+, Kindle/iBooks, touch flags (game) and world factbook

The basics on my netbook:

  • It’s a Gateway with Windows Vista, a 220 gig harddrive and 2 gig of RAM
  • I bought it about a year ago
  • Accessories bought: a Built case sized for the netbook, external DVD/CD burner
  • Apps I’ve installed: Microsoft Office 2007, Norton, Picasa, FlipShare, Adobe Reader, Seesmic, Skype, Google Talk, Google Chrome, a couple of other things I’m sure.

Granted the iPad is new and exciting, but I think there is still an important role for my netbook — and the laptop I’m using as I type this up!

Where do I anticipate using the iPad most? Short personal trips like this past weekend’s jaunt over to North Carolina for a niece’s graduation.  I was able to check weather, get quick directions, stay up on what’s happening in the world and my social networks.  I uploaded some photos but quite frankly held out for the bulk of things til I returned home.

I also anticipate carrying the iPad along on business trips.  It will be the easy way to stay in touch with friends on social media, give me some diversions along the route and could replace the GPS I have been known to carry.  For instance, I carried it yesterday for the few hours I was spending in the backseat of a pickup going to and from an event that was able to be highlighted through twitter (I was so psyched to see Mashable’s post on twitterific integrating twitpic cause it took a few minutes to figure out uploading this one), etc.

The biggest advantages of the iPad for me so far seem to be:

  • Ease of use in tight quarters like the truck or the coach seat I had.  This has gotten tougher with full-sized laptops and netbooks alike as it seems the person in front of me ALWAYS feels a need to recline fully.
  • The fact it EASILY fit into a normal sized purse, camera bag, etc.  Granted, you know there is something a bit bigger in there than normal, but I’m amazed at how well it slides into everything.
  • Speed of access — this thing took no time to get going or to access wireless or cellular towers whether I was in the city or driving down a state road with flooded fields on either side of me.
  • Simple click throughs for quick program access.

Do I still need a netbook? If not, why? If so, where does it fit? Other people will answer this differently, but I think the netbook remains a keeper for me.  I love to travel and take photos. If I’m doing a trip that is heavy on photography, a higher performing machine and bigger harddrive is going to make sense.  There are also some times when I’m working on a personal passion project that involves spreadsheets, presentations, etc.  The netbook is a great way for me to go there.  However, I think I’ll appreciate not needing that much room in the briefcase moving forward on many business trips.

So the biggest advantages of the netbook:

  • Lots of storage — can keep a lot of photos there to be shared or simply backed up.
  • Full software set to edit, view, etc.
  • Ability to accommodate Flip video camera & do some video editing, etc.  (though I see some blogs saying there is a way to play flip videos, I haven’t seen any saying you can import from the camera, if you know a way, please share!)

What piece of technology is the loser in the smackdown? I will likely not use the netbook as much as I did in the past but I do anticipate it having a real fit.  The iPad will be fun and useful at home (especially during storms when power takes out modems/routers like this post), around town (like this evening when I grabbed a bite and caught up on the news or last weekend when I showed my hairstylist pictures from her son’s facebook account while we caught up) and definitely a fun and useful add for travel.

What do you think?

  • If you don’t have an iPad or netbook, you may want to consider something that makes you more mobile particularly for blogging, twitter, etc.  Although smartphones are a great tool, either of these can really take you up a notch or two.
  • If you have an iPad, tell me what apps you are using and why and you should feel free to ask me questions on mine.
  • If you have questions, ask away.

About Janice Person

I'm Janice & this blog is about my passions -- photography, travel, agriculture & whatever else comes to mind. Putting all those things together is intriguing to me…. I can spend a lot of time soaking it up! It's almost always a colorful adventure!

, , ,

6 Responses to Will my iPad put the smackdown on my netbook?

  1. Kelly May 13, 2010 at 10:09 am #

    Love the post, JP. Great read, good talking points. It does antagonize my MacGeek-addict-craving a bit. I’d love an iPad, but since I go everywhere with my MacBook, I think I can handle waiting 😉

  2. Janice July 13, 2010 at 10:27 am #

    I wasn’t actually driving (lol) but I have the 3G model which has built in mobile access like the iPhone or Blackberry. It has been AWESOME! And it still pulls wifi when that is available. For those of us in agriculture and using social media, I think this is a great fit. For instance, I’m at break from a meeting in a local hotel as I reply. Don’t need to pay for wireless. (love places with free wifi).


  1. Lots Learned in Two Months of iPad Use « ag – a colorful adventure for this city girl - July 13, 2010

    […] the 3G model was available. I had such high expectations but I also had a lot of questions. One I blogged about was where my iPad would fair versus the notebook I had been counting on for more than a year. That […]

  2. It is official! The iPad has put the smackdown on my netbook! | ag – a colorful adventure - December 23, 2010

    […] There was a time that shall be known as BI — before iPad. Back in those dark days, I was under the mistaken impression that I was able to keep up with things in my personal digital world even when I was on the move thanks to a netbook. I have trouble remembering this at all but luckily I have a blog post to remind me. […]

  3. My Thoughts – Christmas morning (or any first-day) help for the new iPad owner | Rex Hammock’s RexBlog.com | ag – a colorful adventure - December 25, 2010

    […] My initial thoughts on the iPad and the netbook — Having been a major user of my netbook for personal things while traveling or at the house, I wasn’t sure how the two would be used. I found a few programs on the beginning and started going. […]

  4. The Constant Decision of Whether to Upgrade or Not - The Mobile Farmer - June 25, 2011

    […] Friends and family have come to expect me to have the latest technology, especially around computers and cameras. I’m the person who had the first digital camera in my part of the world and who soon after was pushing for the smallest one on the market. With my love of music, I got addicted to iPods early and of course, I had to have an iPad as soon as they hit the market (one of my earliest posts on iPads). […]

What are you thinking?